New Jersey Tech, Business, & Creative Resources
Data Centers Aren’t Driving Up Everyone’s Electric Bills. But There’s More to the Story.
In the American debate over electricity, data centers have become the latest villains. And judging by recent election results, plenty of people would rather stop another server farm from being built in their backyard.
Earlier this month, voters in 40 of 41 local ballot races across the country chose to restrict or prohibit new data center construction. This was true for many of them in Ohio. According to a Washington Post report by Shannon Osaka, much of the opposition stems from concerns that these facilities drive up household electricity bills.
One problem: Research suggests that the truth is considerably more complex.
In several studies, it has been found that data centers have only contributed a small amount to the national increase in residential electricity prices. Despite this, certain regions are under greater pressure, and AI infrastructure may demand more energy in the near future.
The distinction is especially significant for New Jersey, which shares a power grid with several states growing rapidly as data centers.
The Research Doesn’t Support the Biggest Claims
According to a new study by researchers at Harvard University and the University of Pennsylvania, electricity prices are closely correlated with data center development.
The researchers estimated that data centers accounted for approximately 4% of utility rate increases between 2020 and 2025.
Wharton School professor Serguei Netessine, one of the study’s authors, said the findings surprised him as well. In the same period, industrial electricity customers experienced approximately a 15% price increase as a result of data centers.
However, the impact was relatively small for residential customers.
Furthermore, the researchers identified several factors that contribute to rising electricity prices, including the cost of natural gas, the age of electrical infrastructure, improvements to the grid, and recovery costs associated with extreme weather events.
In other words, blaming data centers for every increase in electricity bills ignores several much larger factors.
Multiple Studies Reach Similar Conclusions
This finding isn’t unique to Harvard and Penn.
Data centers have been shown to increase average residential electricity prices by approximately 2.1% between 2010 and 2024, according to researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Other research has produced similarly modest results.
In certain regions, the Brattle Group and Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory found that data centers actually reduced electricity costs. Similarly, Electric Power Research Institute research found a 4% reduction in residential electricity prices coincided with doubling of data center capacity between 2019 and 2024.
Brattle Group’s Ryan Hledik told The Washington Post that different research methodologies can lead to slightly different conclusions. According to some studies, prices have increased modestly, while others have decreased modestly. In public discussions, they often fail to show the dramatic nationwide impact on prices.
Additionally, independent analysts question the validity of the blame being placed on data centers.
An October 2025 study highlighted by the Ohio Manufacturers’ Association concluded that rising grid costs, rather than data center development, were responsible for electricity price increases.
Writer Andy Masley reached a similar conclusion in an extensive examination of electricity pricing and data center demand. The study concluded that data centers will not have a measurable impact on average household electricity bills by 2025, although researchers still lack precise information about their effects in states and localities.
That qualification matters. When looking at national averages, a problem may appear smaller than it really is.
How More Electricity Demand Can Actually Lower Prices
Here’s something that seems counterintuitive: Adding enormous electricity consumers to the grid can sometimes make electricity cheaper for everyone else. In the end, it comes down to the way in which power infrastructure is financed.
It’s common for electric utilities to have substantial fixed expenses. Regardless of how much electricity customers consume, power plants, transmission lines, substations, and distribution infrastructure cost enormous amounts to build and maintain.
Adding more demand can reduce the average cost of electricity for existing customers when a utility has excess capacity.
A Big Think analysis discussed estimates from Pacific Gas and Electric suggesting that other customers could save approximately 1% to 2% on monthly electricity bills over the long term for every additional 1,000 megawatts of data center demand.
As you might expect, there is a catch.
The economic benefit depends on the availability of capacity. When a region runs out of electricity, new infrastructure is required, additional generation is needed, or both are needed. In some cases, those investments can make a significant difference to the economics.
Why Some States Are Feeling the Pressure
Across the country, electricity markets operate differently. What consumers ultimately pay depends on factors such as regional grid capacity, generation sources, transmission constraints, and utility regulations.
Consider the PJM Interconnection, which coordinates wholesale electricity across several states, including Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Maryland, Virginia, and Ohio.
PJM has seen significant growth in anticipated electricity demand, led largely by data centers. As a result of the expansion, regional grids have been under increased pressure, and capacity auction prices have risen as a result.
These auctions help ensure that sufficient electricity generation will be available for future demands. In the event of tighter electricity supplies, the cost of securing that capacity may increase, ultimately increasing consumer bills.
In Maryland, for instance, residential electricity prices have increased due to the growth of data centers.
New Jersey has reason to pay attention, too.
A June analysis from the Rutgers policy lab, titled “Mostly Not. Yet.”, examined the relationship between data centers and electricity prices. Researchers cautioned that facilities being planned for AI workloads are substantially larger than those represented in much of existing research.
For New Jersey, the concern isn’t necessarily that one facility will make electricity more expensive in the surrounding ZIP codes. There is a possibility that multiple large developments will increase demand across a regional grid that is already interconnected.
In other words, there’s a possibility that a data center built in Virginia or Pennsylvania could affect New Jersey customers’ electricity market prices.
The AI Boom Could Create New Electricity Problems
Additionally, utilities must generate enough electricity to support growing data center demand.
The majority of data centers require highly reliable, uninterrupted power. When renewable energy is unavailable, they cannot simply shut down.
During times of low renewable energy production, utilities may resort to natural gas-fired plants or other dispatchable sources. Transitioning to cleaner energy can be complicated and costly as a result.
As Cybernews has explained, data centers’ continuous electricity requirements can influence which power sources utilities bring online, particularly when renewable generation is limited.
Another challenge is infrastructure. Construction, permitting, and financing are required for new transmission lines, substations, and power generation facilities. A price hike can occur if electricity demand outpaces the capacity of the infrastructure.
As utilities add more generation to the grid, residential electricity prices could become more dependent on data center expansion, according to experts interviewed by The Washington Post.
Compared to previous data centers, the next generation of AI facilities may put significant demands on electricity systems.
Data Centers Have Become a Political Punching Bag
It is not surprising that electricity prices have become a topic of political discussion.
The Democratic Party has increasingly emphasized data center development and Republican support for technology companies during the past few elections.
Texans are paying the price for skyrocketing electricity bills, according to James Talarico, now Texas senator-elect. Likewise, Ohio senator-elect Sherrod Brown warned residents that data center expansion would raise their costs.
The opposing argument is equally direct.
In an interview with Hearst’s Washington bureau, Energy Secretary Chris Wright said data centers aren’t costing Americans more. According to him, spreading infrastructure costs over more consumption will actually help lower electricity prices.
Duke Energy’s CEO has also said data centers will have no impact on customer electricity bills.
Consumer advocates disagree, arguing that ordinary ratepayers are helping finance the data center expansion. A report from the Institute for Energy Research, covered by Independent Women’s Forum, points toward state energy mandates as a more significant contributor to higher electricity costs.
The most prominent voices in this discussion have a stake in the outcome. In addition to the desire of technology companies to expand, utilities are seeking to recover the infrastructure investments they’ve made, and politicians are trying to show that they are protecting their constituents.
As Latitude Media observed, data centers can become an easy target for public frustration over electricity prices. Even if the evidence doesn’t support making them the primary culprit.
Electricity Bills Aren’t the Only Reason People Oppose Data Centers
While most residential electricity price increases are not caused by data centers, opposition to their construction is legitimate.
Electricity costs are only one part of the controversy.
An Associated Press and NORC poll found that nearly two-thirds of Americans are extremely or very concerned about data centers’ potential impact on energy prices, according to Cybernews.
Moreover, more than half of Americans believe that data centers are mostly harmful to the environment, according to Pew Research Center research.
Noise pollution from cooling systems and generators, water consumption, environmental damage, and disruption to residential neighborhoods and natural landscapes have been concerns raised by residents.
Additionally, there is a broader cultural concern. AI’s rapid expansion has created anxiety about employment, privacy, misinformation, and the growing influence of technology companies.
Those already uncomfortable with the direction of artificial intelligence will see data centers as something tangible: expensive, enormous buildings consuming local resources for a technological transformation they did not want.
According to Ryan Hledik, these concerns are increasingly bundled together.
This explains why residents’ minds don’t change when told that data centers aren’t responsible for most electricity price increases. There may be a lot more on their minds than their monthly utility bills.
The Bottom Line: Look Beyond the National Numbers
According to the evidence, data centers contribute relatively little to residential electricity price increases. A number of factors have contributed to the current situation, including natural gas prices, aging infrastructure, extreme weather, and grid modernization.
However, national averages don’t tell the whole story. In areas where data centers are developing rapidly and electricity supplies are limited, next-generation AI facilities could make matters worse.
In New Jersey, the important question is whether PJM can keep up with growing demand without putting disproportionate burdens on its customers.
Rather than relying on political rhetoric, we should look at capacity auctions, utility investment plans, and new power generation projects.
Having a data center doesn’t automatically mean you’ll have to pay more for electricity. But technology companies shouldn’t get a blank check to expand while everyone else figures out how to pay for the infrastructure.
It’s not a question of whether America needs data centers. The question is whether they are being built fairly in terms of costs and benefits.